A jar of Good Earth Peanuts Crunchy Natural Peanut Butter on a solid white background.

PB&J

Nothing beats the classic combo. Our Peanut Butter and Jelly section pairs housemade smooth and crunchy peanut butter, ground fresh right here in Skippers, with real fruit preserves and jams from McCutcheon's, a family owned Maryland company making them the old fashioned way since 1938. Whether you're building the perfect sandwich or just spreading something good on toast, everything here is made with real ingredients and genuine care.

A jar of Good Earth Peanuts Crunchy Natural Peanut Butter on a solid white background.
Natural Peanut Butter - Crunchy
$12.00
Sold Out
A jar of Good Earth Peanuts Smooth Natural Peanut Butter with a red lid and white label, set against a plain white background.
Natural Peanut Butter - Smooth
$12.00
Sold Out
A glass jar of McCutcheon's Grape Jelly with a gold metal lid and a white label featuring green and purple text, set against a plain white background.
Grape Jelly
$15.00
Sold Out
A 20 oz glass jar of McCutcheon's Strawberry Delicious Fruit Preserve with a gold metal lid and a white label featuring green and pink text.
Strawberry Preserves
$14.00
Sold Out
A 20 oz glass jar of McCutcheon's Red Raspberry Seedless Fruit Preserve with a gold metal lid and a white label, isolated on a white background.
Red Raspberry Preserves
$15.00
Sold Out
A glass jar of McCutcheon's Orange Blossom Honey with a gold metal lid and a white label, shown against a plain white background.
Orange Blossom Honey
$21.00
Sold Out
Peanut Butter Spreaders
$5.00
Sold Out